The Difference Between Roof Repair And Replacement: Investing In A New Roof Is A Better Option

When is it time for a replacement? Residential roofing replacement can be much more cost-effective than repair. The biggest misconception is that you need a complete roof replacement, but more often than not, you can replace the damaged area of your roof. Sometimes, roof repairs are just a temporary solution, and a complete roof replacement is a better option. Here are some of the things that you should know about the differences between roof repair and replacement. 

Shingle Age

The age of your shingles is one of the first things to consider when your roof needs repairs. Sometimes, the older shingles might have reached the end of their lifespan, and repairing them might become a more frequent issue that you have to deal with. Therefore, it might be a better option to replace the roof instead of repairing the aging shingles. 


The leaks on your roof can be one of the first signs that it needs to be replaced. While some leaks can easily be repaired, they often hide other damage beneath the surface of the shingles. Therefore, replacing the roofing in these areas is ideal because it will expose the other damage that needs to be addressed. You can also correct problems with the roof design that are causing the leaks when you have your roof replaced. 

Ice Dams

Ice dams are another destructive problem that affects older roofs. Often, the wear of the roof beneath the shingles wear ice dams have been present can be severe. This damage can cause structural issues and water damage inside your home. When you replace your roof, you can have a special ice barrier underlayment installed, which will help prevent this damage in areas that are prone to ice dams. 

Tree Damage

When your roof has serious tree damage, this area of your roof will often need to have the shingles replaced. The problem with this is that the new shingles will not match other roofing, which will eventually wear and need to be replaced too. Therefore, it might be a better investment to replace your entire roof when you are dealing with severe tree damage. 

Repairing a roof is usually a quick fix, but it can become costly over time. A replacement can cost more initially, but it will save you money in the long term. Contact a roofing contractor to have your roof evaluated to decide if residential roof replacement is the right choice.